The Official Laboratorium Jellyfish

The Laboratorium has been brought to you since 2000 by James Grimmelmann. Here's some information about the site and here's my disclosure statement.

Recent Comments

Ayelet Oz, on GBS: Google Books in Israel?, “As I see it, http://books.google.co.il/ is the Hebrew version of Google Books.…”

john walker, on GBS: Macbeth without the Prince, “James A better story title for GBS , could be “The Battle…”

Douglas Fevens, on GBS: Google Editions to Launch This Summer, “The article gives a launch date as “late June or July”. Perhaps…”

Peter G, on Epic Fail, “I fail to discern your point, James.…”

john walker, on GBS: First Digital Humanities Grants Announced, “The biggest selling book, reprinted several times, written by Edgar Allan Poe,…”

john walker, on GBS: Final Version of Samuelson's Future of Books in Cyberspace, “Pamela Samuelson is a clear contender for this years ‘Oliver Sacks trophy’.…”

john walker, on GBS: First Digital Humanities Grants Announced, “The projects sound riveting. I look forward to Titles like- “The songs…”

john walker, on GBS: Final Version of Samuelson's Future of Books in Cyberspace, “Having had a chance to properly read this excellent history( i.e. get…”

Douglas Fevens, on GBS: Open Book Alliance Writes to Congress, “Regarding the comment above: “This newspaper article and my comment to it…”

Frances Grimble, on GBS: First Digital Humanities Grants Announced, “So, how to find out whether copyrighted books are being used for…”

Archives

2010
Jan  Feb  Mar  Apr  May  Jun  Jul 
2009
Jan  Feb  Mar  Apr  May  Jun  Jul  Aug  Sep  Oct  Nov  Dec 
2008
Jan  Feb  Mar  Apr  May  Jun  Jul  Aug  Sep  Oct  Nov  Dec 
2007
Jan  Feb  Mar  Apr  May  Jun  Jul  Aug  Sep  Oct  Nov  Dec 
2006
Jan  Feb  Mar  Apr  May  Jun  Jul  Aug  Sep  Oct  Nov  Dec 
2005
Jan  Feb  Mar  Apr  May  Jun  Jul  Aug  Sep  Oct  Nov  Dec 
2004
Jan  Feb  Mar  Apr  May  Jun  Jul  Aug  Sep  Oct  Nov  Dec 
2003
Jan  Feb  Mar  Apr  May  Jun  Jul  Aug  Sep  Oct  Nov  Dec 
2002
Jan  Feb  Mar  Apr  Jun  Jul  Aug  Sep  Oct  Nov  Dec 
2001
Jan  Feb  Mar  Apr  May  Jun  Jul  Sep  Oct  Nov  Dec 
2000
Jan  Mar  May  Jun  Jul  Aug  Sep  Oct  Nov  Dec 
1999
Jan  Feb  Mar  Sep 
1998
Jan  May  Jun  Sep  Nov 
1997
Sep 
1995
Nov 
1993
Oct 
1992
Oct 


Old Sideblog Archive


Pondering Potter Archive

I’ve been asked about the legal significance of the various “declarations” filed in the case. As long as I’m answering, I thought I might as well answer publicly.

In short, a declaration, as a document filed with a court, is just evidence. It’s presented so that the evidence is available to the court. The key word is “available.” It’s subject to the other rules governing the receipt of evidence: e.g., there must be a reason to believe the author actually has knowledge of what she says, the fact-finder might decide not to believe what she says, and so on. But assuming it gets past those other hurdles, the court can use the facts the author asserts in support of its decision. Like testimony in court or physical exhibits, a declaration provides evidentiary support.

You also can’t generally just make up stuff and put it in a declaration. The author typically signs it on oath under penalty of perjury, and the lawyer submitting it takes responsibility for not knowingly presenting falsehoods to the court.

Thanks, James. That’s very helpful. So could anyone have submitted a declaration about the GBS? For instance, could I have put my findings about mistakes in the database in a declaration and formally filed it as evidence. Or would I have had to ask someone (the court, the defendents, the plaintiffs) for permission first. And are deadlines for declarations different from deadlines for objections?

An opt-out or objection letter could also contain information; many of them have. The court doesn’t necessarily need it to be in declaration form for it to be considered. Whether the court would consider filings (whether they’re “declarations” or not) identifying additional facts you think would be of interest is a question that might be better addressed to Judge Chin’s chambers — since the deadlines and procedures are all matters that come from his orders, rather than being externally imposed.

Post a comment



You can use HTML style tags or Markdown.

Comment Preview: