The Official Laboratorium Jellyfish

The Laboratorium has been brought to you since 2000 by James Grimmelmann. Here's some information about the site and here's my disclosure statement.

Recent Comments

Ayelet Oz, on GBS: Google Books in Israel?, “As I see it, http://books.google.co.il/ is the Hebrew version of Google Books.…”

john walker, on GBS: Macbeth without the Prince, “James A better story title for GBS , could be “The Battle…”

Douglas Fevens, on GBS: Google Editions to Launch This Summer, “The article gives a launch date as “late June or July”. Perhaps…”

Peter G, on Epic Fail, “I fail to discern your point, James.…”

john walker, on GBS: First Digital Humanities Grants Announced, “The biggest selling book, reprinted several times, written by Edgar Allan Poe,…”

john walker, on GBS: Final Version of Samuelson's Future of Books in Cyberspace, “Pamela Samuelson is a clear contender for this years ‘Oliver Sacks trophy’.…”

john walker, on GBS: First Digital Humanities Grants Announced, “The projects sound riveting. I look forward to Titles like- “The songs…”

john walker, on GBS: Final Version of Samuelson's Future of Books in Cyberspace, “Having had a chance to properly read this excellent history( i.e. get…”

Douglas Fevens, on GBS: Open Book Alliance Writes to Congress, “Regarding the comment above: “This newspaper article and my comment to it…”

Frances Grimble, on GBS: First Digital Humanities Grants Announced, “So, how to find out whether copyrighted books are being used for…”

Archives

2010
Jan  Feb  Mar  Apr  May  Jun  Jul 
2009
Jan  Feb  Mar  Apr  May  Jun  Jul  Aug  Sep  Oct  Nov  Dec 
2008
Jan  Feb  Mar  Apr  May  Jun  Jul  Aug  Sep  Oct  Nov  Dec 
2007
Jan  Feb  Mar  Apr  May  Jun  Jul  Aug  Sep  Oct  Nov  Dec 
2006
Jan  Feb  Mar  Apr  May  Jun  Jul  Aug  Sep  Oct  Nov  Dec 
2005
Jan  Feb  Mar  Apr  May  Jun  Jul  Aug  Sep  Oct  Nov  Dec 
2004
Jan  Feb  Mar  Apr  May  Jun  Jul  Aug  Sep  Oct  Nov  Dec 
2003
Jan  Feb  Mar  Apr  May  Jun  Jul  Aug  Sep  Oct  Nov  Dec 
2002
Jan  Feb  Mar  Apr  Jun  Jul  Aug  Sep  Oct  Nov  Dec 
2001
Jan  Feb  Mar  Apr  May  Jun  Jul  Sep  Oct  Nov  Dec 
2000
Jan  Mar  May  Jun  Jul  Aug  Sep  Oct  Nov  Dec 
1999
Jan  Feb  Mar  Sep 
1998
Jan  May  Jun  Sep  Nov 
1997
Sep 
1995
Nov 
1993
Oct 
1992
Oct 


Old Sideblog Archive


Pondering Potter Archive

As I said a year and a half ago:

Amazon’s named the device the Kindle, “to evoke the crackling ignition of knowledge,” in journalist Steven Levy’s phrase. Unfortunately, the name is more revealing than intended. The only “crackling ignition” most Kindle users will hear is the sound of their e-books going up in flames.

In related news, I now own a Kindle and I love it. It’s an amazingly convenient way to read, and I expect it to cause a substantial increase in my fiction consumption. With Amazon’s help, we’re finally figuring out how to do e-books right.

That’s why it’s all the more important to get the law and policy right, too. With dead-tree media, the bookstore can’t come to your house and steal back your books, and copyright law doesn’t put pressure on them to try. It’s time for a real law of digital property, one that’s capable of trumping intellectual property, just as first sale rights in physical property trump intellectual property.

James, has Amazon at all changed its DRM policies? Or do you think the convenience of the device outweighs DRM’s flaws?

Like Steven, I’d be curious to know why/when the bit flipped from “the DRM should be a deal-killer for Joe Consumer” to “I now own a Kindle and I love it.”

I’m still in the ‘DRM is a deal-killer’ camp, but it is only a matter of time before I buy something in this class. The only real question is if I vote with my dollars now by buying another device that comes less tethered to DRM, or wait it out for Kindle to become less DRM-y, or if I should just go ahead and get the Kindle because my dollars don’t matter anyway.

(The irony of all this is that it was Amazon’s mp3 store that finally allowed me to ditch buying mp3s after years and years of waiting.)

One factor is that I got mine as a gift. Another is that I treat anything I “buy” for it as potentially subject to Amazon’s calling backsies. So far, I’ve primarily been using it for books I don’t expect to need to hang onto once I finish reading them. A third factor is that, contrary to my initial assessment, it’s now relatively simple to put your own content, from whatever source, onto the Kindle. I plan to start converting PDFs of law review articles and reading them that way. That recreates the iPod ecology if you stock it with MP3s.

I didn’t actually own an ipod, for similar reasons. (I did own other similar devices that weren’t so intimately tied to a leading purveyor of DRM.) But yeah, there are a fair number of sources of content out there that aren’t a problem; some friends are working on high-speed book ripping as well, which may reduce some of my other concerns. (I’d heard that pdfs don’t actually convert that well, but obviously the DX eliminates that concern.) But yeah, I wouldn’t look a gift-horse/reader in the mouth.

(Obviously in my previous comment I meant that it was Amazon’s DRM-free mp3 store that allowed me to ditch CDs, not ditch mp3s.)

Post a comment



You can use HTML style tags or Markdown.

Comment Preview: